A response.

Previously posted amateur graphics who now moved on to giving her 2 cents on anything and everything to do with Harry Potter (with other fandoms and issues on the side).

Personal tumblr can be found here.

harrypotterconfessions:

These are two different books.
Two different plot.
ONE isn’t better than the other.
‘cause they are UNIQUELY built
by their respective creator’s imagination.
That’s why i don’t understand why people 
are so much in the need on comparing which one 
is better. 
Some of the people who says “Twilight sucks!” doesn’t even know how to write a short story. You guys must know how hard it is for both of the authors to create a novel series. 
I have read both of the books.
And I think, they are both incredible. 
Please Respect that.
graphic submitted.

I disagree in everything you’ve just said but I’ll focus on one aspect because this kind of reasoning has always irked me: “Some of the people who says “Twilight sucks!” doesn’t even know how to write a short story.” 
Agreed that not everyone can write well or come up with an original plot like authors do but isn’t that the whole point of being an author? To create good, quality books for us readers? On the other hand, it is our— their consumer and audience— right to criticize their works. So NO. Just because majority of readers do not know how to write does not mean we don’t have the right to complain if the book we just picked up and bought was a crappy one.

harrypotterconfessions:

These are two different books.

Two different plot.

ONE isn’t better than the other.

‘cause they are UNIQUELY built

by their respective creator’s imagination.

That’s why i don’t understand why people 

are so much in the need on comparing which one 

is better. 

Some of the people who says “Twilight sucks!” doesn’t even know how to write a short story. You guys must know how hard it is for both of the authors to create a novel series. 

I have read both of the books.

And I think, they are both incredible. 

Please Respect that.

graphic submitted.

I disagree in everything you’ve just said but I’ll focus on one aspect because this kind of reasoning has always irked me: “Some of the people who says “Twilight sucks!” doesn’t even know how to write a short story.” 

Agreed that not everyone can write well or come up with an original plot like authors do but isn’t that the whole point of being an author? To create good, quality books for us readers? On the other hand, it is our— their consumer and audience— right to criticize their works. So NO. Just because majority of readers do not know how to write does not mean we don’t have the right to complain if the book we just picked up and bought was a crappy one.

(via playoninfiniterepeat)

  1. jessicaarenee reblogged this from thoughtsinhtml
  2. tacosandrainbows reblogged this from pixiedawn77
  3. kyromemikkano reblogged this from amlemons-official
  4. bonnienoire liked this
  5. wingardium-leviosahhh liked this
  6. fried-cheesecake reblogged this from poostpoost
  7. hungarysovaries liked this
  8. claire-fairy reblogged this from poostpoost and added:
    ^once again, with Lori.
  9. poostpoost reblogged this from nic-cages-dick and added:
    ^ both are books so of course theyre gonna be compared its like comparing apples and oranges. sure it sounds ridiculous...
  10. nic-cages-dick reblogged this from alexmochi
  11. alexmochi reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions and added:
    story” Dude, you don’t need...be good at cooking to know if something tastes good. Same...
  12. alt-14-equals-music reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions and added:
    No. Twilight ‘sucks’ because of multiple reasons. Truth be told NEITHER of these series was incredibly well-written, but...
  13. chibikemushi liked this
  14. eternamentesognare reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions
  15. discovercat liked this
  16. melody-nelson liked this
  17. diabolicalnerd liked this
  18. xjmaex reblogged this from webothlikeabe and added:
    Hats off to you.
  19. webothlikeabe reblogged this from stinahawwk
  20. webothlikeabe liked this
  21. stinahawwk reblogged this from peppermonster
  22. desireevanitydisaster reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions
  23. livelikeasavior liked this
  24. thisrestlessheart reblogged this from ihateyouespecially and added:
    Couldn’t have said it better myself.
  25. unpolishedpearl reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions and added:
    all, if you’re going...defend a shitty book series like Twilight and make the assertion...
  26. peppermonster reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions
  27. hallieoliviacollins liked this
  28. ihateyouespecially reblogged this from pixiedawn77
  29. hermionesbookshelf reblogged this from bronzedragon and added:
    # I agree with bronzeddragon (above) and with miss-placed, who also made the point about a person not having to be an...
  30. jessicaellejay reblogged this from icmayla and added:
    Except the comments that are not the first are true.
  31. icmayla reblogged this from kelly-thistle and added:
    The last two comments tho.
  32. gwehyddarbyd reblogged this from tehsunshine and added:
    Ha! Yes. Also, why is is that some people spout an opinion and demand it be respected? What does that even mean? My...
  33. sablia liked this
  34. pixiedawn77 reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions
  35. disaster-incarnate reblogged this from speakingofapplepie and added:
    Sorry, can’t agree with this because I have also read the twilight and harry potter series’ and twilight is truly just a...
  36. syntaria liked this
  37. justanaverageteen reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions
  38. myfinaltrick reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions and added:
    The fact that you said “Some...‘Twilight sucks!’...know…”...
  39. kalaura liked this
  40. giraffecakes reblogged this from getyourhotrodsreadytorumble and added:
    Sam, I love you.
  41. giraffecakes liked this
  42. alexosaurusrex liked this
  43. themendiolapersuasion reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions
  44. ghost-plot reblogged this from bronzedragon
  45. bronzedragon reblogged this from harrypotterconfessions and added:
    If you used this argument in real life, literary criticism wouldn’t exist and no one would ever be able to say that...
  46. shimozu reblogged this from galactic-kat and added:
    Here’s the thing. If I can’t finish a book because of how poorly it’s written, or how sappy or bad the story is, or the...
  47. our-july-in-the-rain reblogged this from alltimebl0wjob
  48. shimozu liked this
  49. theboaby reblogged this from tehsunshine
  50. tehsunshine reblogged this from kelly-thistle and added:
    Yeah… actually, there’s just one plot. Because Harry Potter has one and Twilight really doesn’t. But nice try.

original theme by blackishgray /// archive /// liked posts ❤